Amazon Flex vs Other Delivery Apps: Complete 2025 Comparison
Detailed comparison of Amazon Flex vs DoorDash, Uber Eats, Instacart, and more. Real pay data, requirements, pros/cons to help you choose the best delivery app.
💰 Real Pay Data
📊 Side-by-Side
🆕 2025 Updated
Quick Comparison Overview
| App | Avg Hourly | Vehicle | Schedule | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon Flex | $16-25 | Mid-size+ | Block-based | Higher pay, flexibility |
| DoorDash | $12-20 | Any size | Instant on/off | Immediate availability |
| Uber Eats | $10-18 | Any size | Instant on/off | Urban markets |
| Instacart | $14-22 | Mid-size+ | Batch-based | Tips, customer service |
| Grubhub | $11-19 | Any size | Scheduling blocks | Guaranteed minimums |
Which App Should I Choose?
Your Preferences
Recommendation
🤔
Select your preferences to get a personalized recommendation
Detailed App-by-App Comparison
Based on analysis of thousands of driver experiences across platforms, here's how Amazon Flex compares to other major delivery apps in 2025.
Amazon Flex vs DoorDash
Pay Comparison
Amazon Flex Pay
- • Base: $18-25/hour
- • Surge: $25-40/hour
- • Tips: Fresh/Whole Foods only
- • Average: $16-25/hour net
DoorDash Pay
- • Base: $2-4 per delivery
- • Tips: $2-8 per delivery
- • Peak pay: +$1-5 per delivery
- • Average: $12-20/hour net
requirements Comparison
| Requirement | Amazon Flex | DoorDash |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum age | 21 years | 18 years |
| Vehicle size | Mid-size sedan+ | Any vehicle |
| Background check | Comprehensive | Standard |
| Approval time | 2-7 days | Same day |
Amazon Flex vs DoorDash: Pros and Cons
Choose Amazon Flex If:
- ✅ You want higher pay potential
- ✅ You have a larger vehicle
- ✅ You prefer planned work blocks
- ✅ You don't mind less frequent availability
- ✅ You want tips on grocery deliveries
Choose DoorDash If:
- ✅ You want to start working immediately
- ✅ You have a smaller vehicle
- ✅ You prefer instant on/off scheduling
- ✅ You want consistent availability
- ✅ You prefer shorter delivery distances
Amazon Flex vs Uber Eats
Earnings Comparison
Amazon Flex Advantages
- • 25-40% higher base pay rates
- • Surge blocks can reach $40-50/hour
- • Less competition for high-paying blocks
- • Longer blocks = fewer startup costs
Uber Eats Advantages
- • More frequent surge pricing
- • Better for urban short-distance deliveries
- • Can work with bike/scooter in some cities
- • Instant availability
Market Presence
- Amazon Flex: Available in 50+ US cities, growing steadily
- Uber Eats: Available in 6,000+ cities worldwide, most established
- Winner: Uber Eats for availability, Amazon Flex for pay in available markets
Amazon Flex vs Instacart
Service Type Comparison
Amazon Flex
- • Service: Package delivery + some grocery
- • Shopping: No shopping required
- • Customer interaction: Minimal
- • Route efficiency: Pre-planned routes
Instacart
- • Service: Grocery shopping + delivery
- • Shopping: Required - can be time-consuming
- • Customer interaction: Extensive communication
- • Tips: Generally higher than Amazon Fresh
Earning Potential Breakdown
- Amazon Flex Fresh: $20-35/hour including tips
- Amazon Flex Logistics: $18-25/hour (no tips)
- Instacart: $14-22/hour including tips
- Winner: Amazon Flex for higher guaranteed minimum
Amazon Flex vs Grubhub
Scheduling Systems
Amazon Flex Scheduling
- • Block-based system (3-6 hour blocks)
- • Grab blocks in advance
- • Guaranteed pay for full block
- • Less flexible for short work periods
Grubhub Scheduling
- • Schedule blocks or work off-block
- • Guaranteed hourly minimum during blocks
- • More flexibility for part-time work
- • Can log in/out during scheduled blocks
Complete Delivery App Comparison Chart
| Factor | Amazon Flex | DoorDash | Uber Eats | Instacart |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average hourly pay | $16-25 | $12-20 | $10-18 | $14-22 |
| Peak pay potential | $35-50 | $25-35 | $20-30 | $25-40 |
| Availability | Limited blocks | High | High | Moderate |
| Vehicle requirements | Mid-size+ | Any car | Any vehicle | Mid-size+ |
| Minimum age | 21 | 18 | 18 | 18 |
| Customer interaction | Minimal | Minimal | Minimal | Extensive |
| Best markets | Major cities | All markets | Urban areas | Suburban+ |
Multi-App Strategy: Best Combinations
Amazon Flex + DoorDash
💡 Popular Combination
- Strategy: Use Amazon Flex for scheduled blocks, DoorDash to fill gaps
- Benefits: Higher pay from Flex + consistent availability from DoorDash
- Best for: Drivers who want to maximize income and availability
- Vehicle requirement: Mid-size sedan or larger
Amazon Flex + Instacart
🛒 Grocery-Focused Strategy
- Strategy: Focus on tip-eligible deliveries from both platforms
- Benefits: Higher tip potential, similar vehicle requirements
- Best for: Drivers who excel at customer service
- Considerations: More customer interaction required
Which App Pays the Most?
By Average Hourly Earnings (After Expenses)
- Amazon Flex: $16-25/hour average, $35-50 peak
- Instacart: $14-22/hour average, $25-40 peak
- DoorDash: $12-20/hour average, $25-35 peak
- Grubhub: $11-19/hour average, $20-30 peak
- Uber Eats: $10-18/hour average, $20-30 peak
By Market Conditions
- High-demand urban markets: Amazon Flex wins for gross pay
- Suburban markets: Instacart often competitive due to tips
- Rural markets: DoorDash often most available
- Peak times: Amazon Flex surge pricing typically highest
Best Apps by Driver Type
For New Drivers
🚀 Getting Started
- Best choice: DoorDash or Uber Eats
- Why: Faster approval, any vehicle, immediate availability
- Strategy: Start here, then apply to Amazon Flex once established
For Experienced Drivers
💰 Maximizing Earnings
- Best choice: Amazon Flex + one backup app
- Why: Highest pay rates, can fill gaps with other apps
- Strategy: Prioritize Flex blocks, use others for additional income
For Part-Time Side Hustlers
⏰ Flexible Schedule
- Best choice: DoorDash or Uber Eats
- Why: Instant on/off, work around other commitments
- Strategy: Use when convenient, no commitment to blocks
Regional Considerations
East Coast Markets
- NYC Metro: Amazon Flex and Instacart lead in pay
- Boston: Strong Flex market, DoorDash for consistency
- Washington DC: Amazon Flex dominates suburban areas
West Coast Markets
- Seattle: Amazon Flex pays premium rates ($25-40/hour)
- San Francisco: All apps viable, Flex pays best
- Los Angeles: Uber Eats and DoorDash more available
Midwest and South
- Chicago: Good market for all apps
- Atlanta: Amazon Flex growing, DoorDash established
- Dallas: Balanced market, all apps competitive
Future Outlook: 2025 Trends
Amazon Flex Expansion
- New markets: 10-15 new cities expected in 2025
- Same-day delivery growth: More high-paying blocks
- Fresh/Whole Foods expansion: More tip opportunities
Competition Response
- DoorDash: Improving driver pay to compete
- Uber Eats: Expanding grocery delivery
- Instacart: Increasing batch pay rates
Bottom Line Recommendation
If you meet Amazon Flex requirements and can access blocks in your market, it typically offers the highest earning potential among delivery apps.
Best strategy: Start with Amazon Flex as your primary app, use DoorDash or Uber Eats to fill gaps, and consider Instacart if you enjoy customer service and shopping.